There’s something special about watching your dog’s excitement as they discover a brand-new toy. The wagging tail, the happy bark, the joyful zoomies — it’s pure happiness! But finding the perfect toy every time can be exhausting for dog owners. That’s where dog toy subscription boxes come in.
These magical monthly boxes deliver curated toys, treats, and goodies straight to your doorstep. Whether you have a power chewer, a snuggle bug, or a hyper puppy, there’s a subscription box designed just for your dog’s personality and play style.
In this article, we’ll explore the best dog toy subscription boxes that offer endless fun, variety, and joy for your pup — while making your life easier. From budget-friendly options to premium experiences, we’ve got something for every pet parent.
Why Dog Toy Subscription Boxes Are Worth It
Before jumping into our top picks, let’s explore why these subscription boxes are more than just a trend.
1. Endless Variety and Surprise
Every month brings a new adventure! Subscription boxes keep playtime exciting by introducing different textures, shapes, and themes. This constant novelty helps prevent boredom and destructive behavior — a common issue in dogs that lack mental stimulation.
2. Mental and Physical Stimulation
Rotating new toys helps keep your dog’s mind sharp. Toys that squeak, crinkle, or puzzle your pup engage their senses and challenge their brain. Combined with the joy of chewing, tugging, and fetching, it’s a great way to promote both mental and physical health.
3. Tailored for Every Dog’s Needs
Most services personalize boxes based on your dog’s size, breed, chewing style, and preferences. Got a husky who loves tug-of-war or a small terrier obsessed with squeaky toys? There’s a box tailored just for them.
4. Cost-Effective Fun
Buying toys separately can be expensive, and not all last long. Subscription boxes often deliver premium-quality toys at a fraction of the retail price — plus surprise treats, bandanas, and even grooming essentials.
5. Strengthening the Human-Dog Bond
Unboxing together becomes a shared experience. Watching your pup explore the contents of their new box creates joyful moments and strengthens your bond through play and affection.
Top Dog Toy Subscription Boxes You’ll Love
Here’s a curated list of the most-loved dog toy subscription boxes — tested, reviewed, and adored by pups and their humans alike!
A. BarkBox – The Original Favorite
Perfect for: Dogs of all sizes who love themed toys and tasty treats.
Why It’s Awesome:
BarkBox is one of the most popular dog subscription boxes, and for good reason. Each month features a fun theme — like “Under the Seaside” or “Space Pups” — packed with 2 innovative toys, 2 full-size treats, and a chew.
Pros:
-
Customizable for allergies or chewing style
-
Toys are durable yet adorable
-
Great customer service
Estimated Price: $23/month
B. Super Chewer – Built for Tough Pups
Perfect for: Heavy chewers and large breeds.
Why It’s Awesome:
From the same creators as BarkBox, Super Chewer delivers ultra-tough toys that withstand even the strongest jaws. Each box includes 2 indestructible toys, 2 meaty treats, and 2 chews.
Pros:
-
Long-lasting rubber and nylon toys
-
Lifetime replacement guarantee
-
Excellent value for strong dogs
Estimated Price: $30/month
C. PupJoy – Custom Boxes for Every Dog Personality
Perfect for: Pet parents who want full customization.
Why It’s Awesome:
PupJoy allows you to choose everything — from toy types to treat ingredients. You can even select “eco-friendly” or “USA-made only” options.
Pros:
-
Personalized curation
-
Ethical and natural products
-
Supports small pet brands
Estimated Price: $25–$40/month
D. Bullymake Box – Made for Power Chewers
Perfect for: Dogs who destroy toys in minutes.
Why It’s Awesome:
Bullymake specializes in tough nylon, rubber, and ballistic fabric toys designed for aggressive chewers. Each box includes 2–3 indestructible toys and 3 full-sized treats.
Pros:
-
Made in the USA
-
Toys last for months
-
Excellent for large breeds
Estimated Price: $31/month
E. Pet Treater Box – Budget-Friendly Fun
Perfect for: Dog owners who want great value on a budget.
Why It’s Awesome:
Pet Treater provides a mix of toys, treats, and accessories at a very affordable price. Even though it’s cheaper, the quality is surprisingly impressive!
Pros:
-
Lowest price point
-
Great mix of items
-
Ships quickly
Estimated Price: $18/month
How to Choose the Right Subscription for Your Dog
Picking the right subscription can feel overwhelming with so many great options. Here’s a guide to help you decide.
Step 1: Know Your Dog’s Play Style
Observe whether your pup prefers tugging, fetching, chewing, or cuddling. This will help you pick a box that aligns with their energy level and toy preferences.
Step 2: Consider Food Sensitivities
If your dog has allergies, pick a box that offers limited-ingredient or grain-free treats. Brands like PupJoy and BarkBox offer allergen-free options.
Step 3: Evaluate Durability
If your dog tears through plushies in minutes, consider Super Chewer or Bullymake. For gentler pups, BarkBox or Pet Treater is perfect.
Step 4: Set a Monthly Budget
Boxes range from $18 to $40 per month. Remember that you’re getting 4–6 products — usually worth more than what you pay.
Step 5: Rotate and Refresh Toys
Keep older toys in rotation. Dogs love rediscovering toys after a short break — it keeps playtime exciting without spending extra.
Bonus Tip: Sustainable Choices
If you’re eco-conscious, choose boxes that use recyclable packaging or eco-friendly materials. PupJoy offers excellent sustainable options.
Subscription Boxes = Endless Tail Wags
Dog toy subscription boxes are more than just a fun surprise — they’re a way to nurture your dog’s happiness, health, and curiosity. With so many customizable and affordable options, finding the best dog toy subscription box has never been easier.
So go ahead — treat your furry friend to a monthly surprise of joy, and watch their eyes light up with excitement every time that special box arrives!